How do you choose between AIR RMU and GIS RMU in power systems?

AIR RMU (Air-insulated Ring Main Unit) and GIS RMU (Gas-insulated ring Main Unit) are the two mainstream types of ring main units. The core difference lies in the different insulating media. Simply put: Different insulating media are like different materials of "water pipes" - some use "AIR" as the water pipe (AIR RMU), and some use "SF₆ gas", a kind of "special material water pipe" with better sealing and stronger performance (GIS RMU). The purpose of all is to firmly "lock" the high-voltage electricity in the right place.

Air RMU (Air-Insulated Ring Main Unit)
Dry air is used as the main insulating medium, and the insulation between high-voltage live components and the cabinet body as well as the grounding part is achieved through the air gap. Solid insulating materials such as epoxy resin may be used as an auxiliary in some key parts.
GIS RMU (Gas-Insulated Ring Main Unit)
Using sulfur hexafluoride (SF₆) gas or its mixed gas as the main insulating medium, SF₆ gas has extremely strong insulating performance and arc-extinguishing ability. The cabinet body is mostly a sealed structure, completely enclosing the high-voltage components in the cavity filled with insulating gas.

The performance of the AIR RMU and GIS RMU difference? What are those?
|
ComparisonDimension |
AIRRMU (Air-InsulatedRingMainUnit) |
GISRMU (Gas-InsulatedRingMainUnit) |
|
Insulation/Arc-Extinguishing Capacity |
Moderate (uses air as insulation medium) |
Extremely strong (uses SF₆ gas as insulation medium) |
|
Environmental Adaptability |
Only suitable for dry and clean indoor environments |
Resistant to humidity, salt spray and corrosion; suitable for outdoor and harsh environments |
|
Size |
Large |
Small (about 1/3 - 1/2 the size of AIR RMU) |
|
Maintenance Requirement |
Frequent (regular dust cleaning and air gap inspection required) |
Minimal (only regular gas pressure and purity testing required) |
|
Safety |
Risk of fault leakage/spillover exists |
Faults easy to isolate (hermetic structure limits the impact of internal faults) |
How to choose between AIR RMU and GIS RMU based on specific circumstances?

1. The situation where AIR RMU is preferred
Clean and dry environment: Installed in indoor distribution rooms (such as ordinary residential areas and office buildings), there are no issues of dust, corrosive gases, or high humidity.
Ample space: The distribution room has sufficient area to accommodate large-sized cabinets without the need to compress installation space.
Budget priority control of initial costs: The procurement budget in the early stage of the project is limited, and the maintenance costs of regular cleaning and inspection in the later stage (such as annually) can be accepted.
The power supply requirements are general: it is used for ordinary lighting and civilian loads, with a relatively small short-circuit current (≤25kA), and the safety requirements for fault isolation are not high.
2. The situation where GIS RMU is given priority
Harsh environment/Outdoor installation: It should be used outdoors, along the coast (salt spray), in chemical industrial areas (corrosive gases), and in rainy and humid regions.
Narrow space: Installed in basements, corridors, and box-type substations, it requires a compact volume (only 1/3 to 1/2 of AIR RMU).
The budget takes into account the full-cycle cost: Although the initial purchase price is high, it is hoped to reduce long-term maintenance (10 to 20 years of low frequency), lower labor and failure risk costs.
High power supply reliability requirements: It is used for critical loads such as hospitals, data centers, and subways, and needs strong insulation, high arc-extinguishing capacity, and no fault spread.

